Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment

Most Popular Links

Listservs

More Resources

Prop. 65 resources

Enforcement

Administrative Listing Mechanism

State’s Qualified Experts Mechanism

More Resources

 

Proposition 65

 

Index of Comments Submitted on the Chemicals to be Considered for Prioritization by the Carcinogen Identification Committee on May 29, 2009 Comment Period Closed May 5, 2009
[05/18/09]

No.

Commenter

Date of Comment

Chemical

49

Robert Winters, Attorney at Law
Hogan & Hartson, LLP
Martin Hahn
Executive Director
International Hydrolyzed Protein Council
Columbia Square
555 13th St.
Washington, DC 20004-1109

5/5/09
via email

1,3-DCP
(cover note & 2-page cover letter with 18‑page attachment)

48

Robert Winters, Attorney at Law
Hogan & Hartson, LLP
Martin Hahn
Executive Director
International Hydrolyzed Protein Council
Columbia Square
555 13th St.
Washington, DC 20004-1109

5/5/09
via email

3-MCPD
(cover note & 4-page cover letter with 25‑page attachment)

4

Pamela Roosma
1811 Amber Leaf Way
Lodi, CA 95242

3/10/09
via email

Aspartame
(1 page)

8

Rich Murray
1943 Otowi Road
Santa Fe, NM 87505

3/31/09
via email

Aspartame
(8 pages)

10

Sukey Smith

4/11/09
via email

Aspartame
(1 page)

13

K. Paul Stoller, MD, FACHM
President, International Hyperbaric Medical Association
Medical Director for:
Hyperbaric Medical Center New Mexico
Hyperbaric Oxygen Clinic Sacramento
Hyperbaris Recovery Center
404 Brunn School Rd. #D
Santa Fe, NM 87505

4/27/09
via email

Aspartame
(cover note & 10-page attachment)

15

James Swenberg, DVM, Ph.D.
Director, Center for Environmental Health & Susceptibility
Director, Curriculum in Toxicology
University of North Carolina
Gillings School of Global Public Health
253C Rosenau Hall
Campus Box 7431
Chapel Hill, NC 27599-7431

5/4/09
via email

Aspartame
(2 pages)

41

David B. Schmidt
President & CEO
Lindsey Loving
Director, Food Ingredient Communications
International Food Information Council
1100 Connecticut Ave. NW, Suite 430
Washington, DC 20036

5/5/09
via email

Aspartame
(5 pages)

53

F. Jay Murray, Ph.D., DABT
Murray & Associates
5529 Perugia Circle
San Jose, CA 95138
On behalf of Calorie Control Council

5/5/09
via email

Aspartame
(24 pages)

37

Debbie Stubbs
Senior Regulatory Manager
State Affairs Department
Syngenta Crop Protection
P.O. Box 18300
Greensboro, NC 27419

5/5/09
via email

Benoxacor
(cover note & 16-page attachment)

43

Caroline Cox
Center for Environmental Health
2201 Broadway, Suite 302
Oakland, CA 94612-3017

5/5/09
via email

Dicofol
(cover note & 9-page attachment)

32

Jonathan T. Busch
Manager, Alkanolamines Panel
Director, Chemical Products and Technology Division
American Chemistry Council
1300 Wilson Blvd.
Arlington, VA 22209

5/5/09
via email

Diethanolamine & triethanolamine
(1-page cover letter & 33-page attachment)

23

John E. Bailey, Ph.D.
Executive Vice President – Science
Personal Care Products Council
(Formerly CTFA)
1101 17th Street N.W., Suite 300
Washington, D.C. 20036-4702

5/4/09
via email

Diethanolamine, Triethanolamine, D & C Yellow No. 11
Fluoride & its salts

(10 pages)

33

Henry I. Miller, MD
The Hoover Institute
Stanford University
434 Galvez Mall
Stanford, CA 94305-6010

5/5/09
via fax

DINP
(2 pages)

36

Laura N. Winks
Oxo Americas Regulatory Affairs Advisor
Exxon Mobil Chemical Company

5/5/09
via email

DINP
#1 (cover note & 12‑page attachment)
#2 (cover note & 44‑page attachment, with 5 attachments [A – 7pp; B – 23pp; C – 20pp; D – 5pp; E – 8pp])
#3 (cover note & 126‑page attachment)

47

Chris Bryant
Managing Director
Chemical Products and Technology Division
American Chemistry Council
Phthalate Esters Panel

5/5/09
via email

DINP
(12 pages)

59

Sarah Janssen, MD, Ph.D., MPH
Staff Scientist
Natural Resources Defense Council
111 Sutter St., 20th floor
San Francisco, CA 94104

5/5/09
via email

DINP, Methoxychlor, PFOA, Permethrin, Tetrachlorvinphos, Triclosan, and Tris(1,3-dichloro-2-propyl) phosphate
(6 pages)

1

Anita Knight
2565 ½ 40th Avenue North
St. Petersburg, FL 33714

3/5/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts (2 pages)

2

Bethany Cole
8115 Calabar Avenue
Playa del Rey, CA 90293

3/9/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(1 page)

3

Donald Beeler
(Chemist, California citizen)

3/9/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(3 pages)

5

Leigh Skinner
San Diego, CA

3/28/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(1 page)

6

Val Healy
Santa Rosa, CA 95401

3/29-09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(1 page)

7

Betsy Anderson
Sebastopol, CA

3/30/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(1 page)

9

Lily Yazdi
San Mateo County

4/7/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(1 page)

11

Del Goetz
President
Marin Community Advocates
237 Mountain View Ave.
Mill Valley, CA 94941

4/17/09

Fluoride & its salts
(31 pages)

12

Rudolf Ziegelbecker, Jr.
Franckstraße 24
8010 Graz
Austria

4/26/09
via email

 

 

4/29/09

5/5/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(12-page email note) & 10 attachments
(3 in English; 7 in non‑English [#1 – 6pp; #2 – 6pp; #3 – 1pp; #4 – 4pp; #5 – 11pp; #6 – 11pp; #7 – 3pp; #8 – 63pp; #9 – 1pp; #10 – 1pp])

3-page note, includes OEHHA 4/30/09 reply)

(8-page note)

16

Jeanette Bajorek

5/2/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(1 page)

17

Marcie Pollock
12th District PTA
Certified Nursing Assistant

5/2/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(1 page)

18

Jason Krueger
5885 NE River Rd.
Sauk Rapids, MN 56379

5/2/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(1 page)

19

Danny Gottlieb
Agriculturalist & Professional Food Technologist (Emeritus)
On behalf of  Citizens for Safe Drinking Water
P.O. Box 578361
Modesto, CA 95357-8361

5/3/09
via email

 

5/5/09
via courier

Fluoride & its salts
(cover note & 24‑page attachment)

 

Flouride & its salts 17 pages & 28-minute DVD & 2-page attachment (DVD not available for download)

20

Roger D. Masters
Research Professor of Government and Nelson A. Rockefeller Professor of Government Emeritus, Department of Government
Dartmouth College
Hanover, NH

5/3/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(cover note & 2 attachments [#1 ‑ 10pp; #2 – 7pp])

21

Paul Connett, Ph.D.
Professor Emeritus Environmental Chemistry
St. Lawrence University
Canto, NY 13617
Executive Director,
Fluoride Action Network

5/4/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(cover note & 12-page attachment)

24

Cynthia Erville

5/4/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(2 pages)

25

Jane Riskin
P.O. Box 462
Pacific Palisades, CA 90272

5/4/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(1 page)

26

Ian E. Packington, MA
Vice-Chair, National Pure Water Association of U.K. and Science Advisor

5/5/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(3 pages)

27

Barbara A. Kochanowski, Ph.D.
Vice President, Regulatory Affairs
Consumer Healthcare Products Association
900 19th Street NW, Suite 700
Washington, DC 20006

5/5/09
via email & courier

Fluoride & its salts
(6 pages)

28

Juanita Cohodas
Laguna Niguel, CA

5/5/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(2 pages)

30

Scott C. Tips
President
National Health Federation
P.O. Box 688
Monrovia, CA 91017

5/5/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(2 pages)

34

Kathleen M. Thiessen, Ph.D.
Senior Scientist
SENES Oak Ridge, Inc.
102 Donner Dr.
Oak Ridge, TN 37830

5/5/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(cover note & 11‑page attachment)

35

Gayle Mathe
Manager, Policy Development
California Dental Association
1201 K St., 14th floor
Sacramento, CA 95814

5/5/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(2-page cover letter & 13-page attachment)

40

Kathleen D. Hamilton
Seal Beach, CA 90740

5/5/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(1 page)

46

Gene Burke
Environmental Health Projects
P.O. Box 358
Santa Monica, CA 90406

5/5/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(3 pages)

58

Chris Neurath
Research Director
American Environmental Health Studies Project and Fluoride Action Network

5/5/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(13 pages and 3 attachments [#1 ‑ 15pp; #2 – 21pp; #3 – 24pp])
Attachment 1 (15 pages)
Attachment 2 (21 pages)
Attachment 3 (24 pages)

60

Peter Van Caulart, Dip., A.Ed., CES, CEI
Director
Environmental Training Institute
Ridgeville, Ontario, Canada

5/5/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts
(1 page)

39

Yiming Li, Ph.D.
Professor and Director
Loma Linda University
School of Dentistry
Center for Dental Research
24876 Taylor St.
Loma Linda, CA 92350

5/4/09
via email

Fluoride & its salts and Triclosan
(3 pages)

14

John L. O’Donoghue, VMD, PhD, DABT
Scientific Advisor & Group Manager
Hydroquinone Group
3915 Clover St.
Honeoye Falls, NY 14472-9319

4/28/09
via email

Hydroquinone comments and 2 attachments

DeCaprio study

Whysner Study

45

Caroline Cox
Center for Environmental Health
2201 Broadway, Suite 302
Oakland, CA 94612-3017

5/5/09
via email

Methoxychlor
(cover note & 34-page attachment)

54

James R. Coughlin, Ph.D.
President
Coughlin & Associates
27881 La Paz Rd, Suite G, PMB 213
Laguna Niguel, CA 92677
On behalf of International Molybdenum Association

5/5/09
via email

Molybdenum trioxide
(cover note & 19 pages with 5 attachments Molybdenum trioxide: [#1 CTL, 2003 27pp; #2 CTL, 2004 38pp; #3 Scott et al, 1991 59pp; #4 Huvinen et al, 2002 10pp; #5 Huvinen et al 1996 7pp])

56

Christian Volz
Counsel for FMC Corporation
McKenna Long & Aldridge
101 California St. 41st floor
San Francisco, CA 94111

5/5/09
via courier & CD

Permethrin
(20 pages)

44

Caroline Cox
Center for Environmental Health
2201 Broadway, Suite 302
Oakland, CA 94612-3017

5/5/09
via email

PFOA
(cover note & 8-page attachment)

50

Danielle Leonard
Altshuler Berzon LLP
177 Post St., Suite 300
San Francisco, CA 94108
On behalf of Labor & Environmental Coalition

5/5/09
via email & courier

PFOA
(10 pages)

57

Stanley W. Landfair
Counsel for E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company (DuPont)
McKenna Long & Aldridge
101 California St. 41st floor
San Francisco, CA 94111

5/5/09
via courier & CD

PFOA
(18 pages & attachments)

51

Environmental Working Group
1436 U St., NW, Suite 100
Washington, DC 20009

5/5/09
via email

PFOA & Fluoride & its salts
(20 pages & 5-page attachment)

31

Angus E. Crane
Executive Vice President, General Counsel
North American Insulation Manufacturers Association (NAIMA)
44 Canal Center Plaza, #310
Alexandria, VA 22314

5/5/09
via email

Rock wool
(cover note &18‑page attachment)

38

Debbie Stubbs
Senior Regulatory Manager
State Affairs Department
Syngenta Crop Protection
P.O. Box 18300
Greensboro, NC 27419

5/5/09
via email

Thiamethoxam
(cover note & 3 attachments [#1 ‑ 14pp; #2 – 20pp; #3 – 39pp])

22

Lisa Navarro, Ph.D., DABT
Director, Product Safety, Toxicology & Regulatory Affairs
Home & Personal Care
Ciba Inc. (now part of BASF)
Schwarzwaldallee 215
Rosenthal 1045.2.42
4002 BASEL
Switzerland

5/4/09
via email & CD

Triclosan
(cover note & 5-page cover letter and 14 attachments [#1 NICNAS, 2009 - 537pp; #2 USEPA, 2008 - 50pp; #3 USEPA, 2007 Chemistry - 10pp; #4 FR Notice 10-29-08 - 3pp; #5 USEPA RED, 2008 - 98pp; #6 USEPA, 2008 Revised RA - 22pp; #7 USEPA, 2008 RA - 68pp; #8 USEPA, 2008 Tox Chapter - 61pp; #9 USEPA, 2008 Occup RA - 38pp; #10 USEPA, 2008 Eco Fate - 42pp; #11 USEPA, 2008 Eco HA - 33pp; #12 USEPA, 2008 Risk Aquatic - 8pp; #13 USEPA, 2008 Dietary RA - 10pp; #14 SCCP, 2009 - 136pp])

29

Martin E. Bernstein, Ph.D.
7 Eastdale Rd.
White Plains, NY 10605

5/5/09
via email

Triclosan
(1 page)

52

Carl D’Ruiz, MPH
Regulatory Affairs
The Dial Corporation
15101 N. Scottsdale Rd.
Scottsdale, AZ 85254-2199

5/5/09
via email

Triclosan
(4 pages)

55

Richard Sedlak
Senior Vice President
Technical & International Affairs
The Soap and Detergent Association
1500 K St. NW, Suite 300
Washington, DC 20005

5/5/09
via email

Triclosan
(2-page cover letter & 29-page attachment)

42

Caroline Cox
Center for Environmental Health
2201 Broadway, Suite 302
Oakland, CA 94612-3017

5/5/09
via email

Triethanolamine
(cover note & 10-page attachment)

 

 
 
Flex Your Power Website
Energy efficiency and conservation information. Find incentives/rebates, technical assistance, retailers, product guides, case studies and more.
AMBER ALERT: Save a Child Amber Alert logo
AMBER ALERT empowers law enforcement, the media and the public to combat abduction by sending out immediate information.